
Hello. This is
Cook's Illustrated's Perfect Chocolate Chip Cookie. I'm sort of conducting a chocolate chip cookie recipe throwdown right now, so expect lots of chocolate chip cookie pictures. This is how I like my chocolate chip cookies: Crisp edges, chewy interior, walnuts, pockets of good quality chocolate, a little saltiness. This recipe pretty much fits the bill. The recipe calls for the butter to be browned prior to mixing in with the sugars (white and dark brown). You then must whisk the sugars, butter and vanilla together until all of the sugar has dissolved. Then, you let it rest for 3 minutes. Then another 30 seconds of whisking. Repeat this cycle three times before gently folding everything else together. There is no additional resting in the fridge like so many other recipes call for, and I like that. Sometimes you just don't want to wait 36 hours to have freshly baked chocolate chip cookies in your mouth. As I type, I do have
New York Times' chocolate chip cookie dough resting in my fridge.
I thought I had found the perfect cookie recipe last year. I even spent months setting the type to letterpress the recipe on 100 cards to give to people to spread the word. No doubt, that cookie still rocks. Thinking about it now is actually making my eyes a little shiny. Damn, those cookies are good.
I tried the
CI recipe a bit over a year ago in a 100 degree kitchen and it didn't fare too well. They baked up wonky with all the wrong texture. I was so burned by it (not literally) that I didn't dare go near the recipe for another 18 months. Now, I feel a little silly about wasting so much of my life not re-trying that recipe out. The
NYT recipe has also been circulating the Internet for years. I'm finally going to give that one a go, too.
In truth, I was never a big fan of chocolate chip cookies. Chips Ahoy suck. Market ones obviously suck. All others (Starbuck's, Costco, Mrs. Fields, any nice bakery really) always seem very one note. Now I'm glad I can turn out ridiculously good chocolate chip (walnut) cookies in my own kitchen. Maybe, one day I can serve them in my own bakery (: